Collection

Contextualizing claim Pope Leo XIV is replacing Cardinal Dolan, who compared Charlie Kirk to saint

The claims range from false quotes to fake images to a rumor about him supposedly playing the jazz trombone under the name "Bobby Prev."

by Nur Ibrahim, Oct. 1, 2025


Image courtesy of Tiziana Fabi/Getty Images


Since the start of Pope Leo XIV's papacy in May 2025, he has been the subject of numerous rumors about things he has said, his political opinions and more. 

As the first American pope in history, many people online have spread fake information about his views on U.S. President Donald Trump's administration, for example.

We have fact-checked a range of rumored quotes attributed to Leo, including false claims he once urged people to "be woke" and said U.S. Vice President JD Vance "flip flops faster than pages in the Bible." We also broke down a rumor about him discussing gender.

Some claims about Leo were less believable, like the false rumor he played the jazz trombone under the name "Bobby Prev" in the 1970s and 80s and fake photos that supposedly showed him "falling" down stairs. 

Here are 12 claims we've investigated about Leo.


By Nur Ibrahim

Nur Nasreen Ibrahim is a reporter with experience working in television, international news coverage, fact checking, and creative writing.

Pope Leo XIV didn't say Trump 'chose the road of darkness, bitterness and lies'

Sept. 30, 2025

"His words mislead, his attacks divide, and his greed for power is tearing this nation apart," P ...

Read More


Pope Leo XIV issued warning from God about Trump and idolatry?

Sept. 29, 2025

According to one popular YouTube video, Pope Leo XIV told parishioners God said about Trump, “Th ...

Read More


What we know about claim Pope Leo XIV deployed priests to immigration courts

July 25, 2025

The claim was rooted in a real event — in June 2025, San Diego priests attended immigration cour ...

Read More


Did Pope Leo XIV announce 15 major reforms for Catholic Church?

July 23, 2025

A series of YouTube videos were the latest in AI-generated content about the pontiff.

Read More


A white man wearing an all-white outfit stands behind a pulpit pictured next a white woman standing behind a microphone wearing a red dress.

Taylor Swift was nominated by Pope Leo XIV for Nobel Peace Prize?

July 21, 2025

The deadline for 2025 Nobel Peace Prize nominations passed on Jan. 31.

Read More


Don't fall for photos of Pope Leo XIV tumbling down stairs

June 11, 2025

The misleading posts included one real photo and two AI-generated images of Pope Leo XIV.

Read More


A white man wearing white robes and a cross around his neck holds his left hand up while looking down.

What we know about Pope Leo XIV's scheduled video appearance at Chicago event

May 29, 2025

The pope is scheduled to deliver a video message on June 14, 2025 at Rate Field, home of the Whi ...

Read More


A white man is claimed to have said, "Vance you flip flop faster than pages in the Bible."

Pope Leo XIV didn't say JD Vance 'flip-flops faster than pages in the Bible'

May 25, 2025

"You've turned religion into a factory for manufacturing votes," Pope Leo XIV allegedly said of ...

Read More


A white man waves. Next to him, white text says, "You cannot follow both Christ and the cruelty of kings. A leader who mocks the weak, exalts himself, and preys on the innocent is not sent by God. He is sent to test you. And many are failing."

No evidence Pope Leo XIV said, 'You cannot follow both Christ and the cruelty of kings'

May 16, 2025

Social media users jumped to conclusions over a quote circulating online.

Read More


A white man with short white receding hair wearing glasses clasps his hands together. He is wearing a traditional red and gold papal robe and a small white skullcap.

Breaking down rumor Pope Leo XIV once said 'gender ideology' creates 'genders that don't exist'

May 13, 2025

The American-born pontiff allegedly said this in 2016 in response to a proposed education curric ...

Read More


A white man wearing robes raises his left hand. To the right, white text says, "To all who sent prayers, love, and hope as I begin this sacred journey — thank you. I accept this role not as a throne, but as a vow: To serve the forgotten, To uplift the broken, To speak plainly where others stay silent. To be called "woke" in a world that sleeps through suffering is no insult — it is Gospel. Woke means awakened by compassion. Guided by truth. Humbled by grace. Committed to justice — not just for some, but for all. So let them mock. Let them sneer. We will still build the Kingdom — not with walls, but with love. Be awake. Be loving. Be woke. — Pope Leo XIV"

Pope Leo XIV didn't once urge people to 'be woke'

May 12, 2025

"To be called 'woke' in a world that sleeps through suffering is no insult - it is Gospel," a me ...

Read More


No proof Pope Leo XIV played jazz trombone under the name 'Bobby Prev'

May 9, 2025

The newly elected pope said in a 2024 interview that he played tennis in his free time but did n ...

Read More


On the left: Pope Leo XIV, an older white man in traditional white papal robes. On the right: Charlie Kirk, a younger white man in a suit.

Contextualizing claim Pope Leo XIV is replacing Cardinal Dolan, who compared Charlie Kirk to saint

Oct. 1, 2025

Here's what's true — and what's false — about rumors that Leo is replacing New York Cardinal Tim ...

Read More



Source code