Fact Check

Photo of Avril Lavigne, Steven Anthony Lawrence Wasn't Found on Osama bin Laden's Hard Drive

The image was a digital composition — that is, a combination of multiple photographs.

by Aleksandra Wrona, Published Feb. 2, 2025


A white man and woman stand next to each other. The man on the left is wearing a jersey with "5" on it, while the woman is wearing a white tank top and cargo pants. A tie is draped around her neck.

Image courtesy of @luigimangio/Threads


Claim:
A photograph of Avril Lavigne and Steven Anthony Lawrence posing together was found saved on Osama bin Laden's hard drive.
Rating:
False

About this rating


A meme circulated on social media in January 2025 claiming that a photograph of Canadian singer Avril Lavigne alongside American actor Steven Anthony Lawrence was found saved on a hard drive belonging to al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden. Under the pretense of the rumor, the image was supposedly discovered when U.S. military officials raided bin Laden's compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan, and killed him in 2011.

The claim has widely circulated on social media, often with the caption: "Just a friendly reminder that Osama bin Laden had this image saved on his hard drive." For example, one Instagram post (archived) featuring the photograph gained almost 650,000 likes as of this writing.

(Instagram user @interestingash.ck)

The post's caption read:

This image, featuring Avril Lavigne in her signature early 2000s punk style alongside Steven Anthony Lawrence was found saved on Osama bin Laden's hard drive during the raid on his compound in 2011. The discovery of such pop culture artifacts among his files was unexpected and showed a bizarre contrast to his public persona. Bin Laden's collection also included other random and seemingly mundane items, which has since sparked curiosity and analysis regarding his interests and daily life during his years in hiding. This particular photo has since become a peculiar part of the narrative surrounding the infamous terrorist leader.

Similar posts circulated on other social media platforms including X, Threads, and Reddit.

The claim that bin Laden had the image of Lavigne and Lawrence saved on his hard drive is false. In addition to the fact that there was no credible evidence to support the claim, the rumor was part of a years-old fictional meme that claims bizarre or funny images were supposedly discovered in bin Laden's digital files — a joke that references the fact that officials really did uncover a variety of documents and books in his possession.

Furthermore, the image was not real. It was digitally created using two separate photographs taken in 2002 and 2005 and features an element (a fried egg graphic on Lawrence's clothing) that wasn't in the original photograph. 

The earliest known example of the digitally created photo dates back to 2019, years after the bin Laden raid.

The Image Was Digitally Created

Photographer Erik Pendzich captured the image of Lavigne at the 2002 MTV Video Music Awards in New York City, according to stock photo websites Alarmy and Shutterstock. Similar images from that event are available on Alarmy and Getty Images (see example below):

(Getty Images)

Meanwhile, Lawrence's image was seemingly taken roughly three years later, at an event hosted by High Roller Magazine. It is unclear who took the in-question photo specifically and where it first appeared online. However, ImageCollect and IMAGO photo websites displayed near-identical photographs of the event (Lawrence is wearing the same outfit and standing by the same "High Roller" backdrop) under the label "Steven Anthony Lawrence at High Roller Magazine's 2nd Annual Celebrate Summer Event hosted by Carolina Bacardi, Vinciguerra Gallery, Hollywood, CA 07-27-05."

The meme's version of the image, however, shows Lawrence with a fried egg graphic on his clothing. Because early versions of the same photograph, including one posted in 2018, do not feature that element, we concluded it was digitally added.

(TinEye search results)

About the Meme

The claim about bin Laden saving the photo of Lavigne and Lawrence stems from an internet meme known as "Friendly Reminder That Osama bin Laden Had This Image Saved On His Hard Drive," according to the KnowYourMeme website. The meme originated in May 2021 and, in addition to the Lavigne-Lawrence photo, claims officials found digital files related to anime and video games during the 2011 raid.

(Reddit user @Anonymous-boi-01)

This meme plays on real information. In 2017, the CIA released thousands of files that officials retrieved from bin Laden's compound, and they included content related to pop culture.

What Was Actually on bin Laden's Hard Drive?

In the weeks following the May 2011 raid, U.S. intelligence analysts examined digital and hard-copy materials recovered from bin Laden's compound as part of their investigation into his operations. 

Between May 2015 and January 2017, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence publicly released three tranches of the documents. Additionally, in November 2017, the CIA released nearly 470,000 files that included a variety of materials such as bin Laden's personal journal and audio and video files.

As The Guardian reported in 2017, "loaded on one computer was video of the Rowan Atkinson comedy Mr Bean dubbed in Pashtu, the local language in western Pakistan and eastern Afghanistan, episodes of the animated programme Wallace and Gromit, and the viral video 'Charlie bit my finger'. There were also more than 30 videos on crocheting." 

Let us note here: While U.S. officials said they obtained these files from bin Laden's compound, that fact does not necessarily mean he personally uploaded, accessed or viewed them.

However, no evidence, including the images released by the CIA, corroborated the claim that bin Laden had the fake photo of Lavigne or Lawrence in his possession. If he had, that fact would have appeared in news stories about the file collections. That was not the case.


By Aleksandra Wrona

Aleksandra Wrona is a reporting fellow for Snopes, based in the Warsaw, Poland, area.


Source code